← Back to the library
DepressionFebruary 5, 2024 · 6 min read

Winston Churchill and His Battle with Depression

A closer look at Churchill's 'black dog,' the creative outlets he valued, and what his story can offer without turning history into a diagnosis.

Illustrated portrait of Winston Churchill with artists' brushes beside Churchill & Depression: Creativity, Coping & Resilience
In this article

Winston Churchill's public image is one of confidence and determination. The more personal story includes low moods, painful setbacks, and a search for relief through creativity and connection. His experience is often described as a lifelong battle with depression, although the precise diagnosis remains disputed. What is well worth exploring is how he made room for interests and relationships beyond the pressures of public life.12

The 'black dog': what Churchill actually wrote

In a July 11, 1911 letter to Clementine, Churchill discussed a doctor who had helped an acquaintance with depression. He wondered whether the doctor might help him “if my Black Dog returns,” then added that it seemed absent at the time. The letter gives us his own words about distress, relief, and openness to possible help—not just a label applied by later biographers.1

The familiar account of repeated, disabling depression draws heavily on his physician Lord Moran's memoir and later interpretations. A 2018 study of medical records, correspondence, and memoirs questioned whether those sources establish major depression or bipolar disorder. The historical record supports a discussion of emotional suffering; it does not justify presenting one retrospective diagnosis as settled fact.2

That distinction does not make his difficult periods less real. Nor should anyone's achievements be used as proof that they could not have experienced mental illness. The question is what the evidence tells us about this individual, not what a successful person is supposedly capable of feeling.

Painting: a different place to put his attention

Churchill's own account of painting is especially revealing. In Painting as a Pastime, he describes leaving the Admiralty in 1915 and struggling with anxiety, reduced influence, and unaccustomed time to dwell on the war. Painting offered an absorbing activity when he felt unable to act on events that mattered deeply to him.3

He began hesitantly, then found pleasure in experimenting with color and learning a new skill. Painting became a lasting interest, not a brief motivational exercise. His studio at Chartwell, preserved by the National Trust, shows the importance this part of life continued to hold for him.34

The hopeful idea here is not that everyone needs to become an artist. It is that an activity can matter without being impressive, profitable, or connected to your main responsibilities. Churchill's description emphasizes enjoyment and discovery rather than the need to produce a masterpiece.3

Writing and speaking: work with meaning

Writing and public speaking were central to Churchill's life. The Churchill Archive traces the sustained work behind his books, correspondence, wit, and speeches. His 1953 Nobel Prize in Literature recognized both historical and biographical writing and his oratory.56

It is reasonable to see these activities as sources of engagement and purpose. It is a further—and unsupported—step to call every speech or book a treatment for depression. We can appreciate what meaningful work offered him without making his productivity into a prescription for everyone else.

For a reader today, purpose may be much smaller and more personal: caring for someone, learning something, or returning to an interest. You do not have to achieve at Churchill's scale for those things to count.

Humor: more than the famous one-liners

Churchill's wit was part of how he communicated, alongside the more serious language of leadership. The archival record is a better place to explore that side of him than a collection of unsourced quotations circulating online.5

Humor can be part of a person's life even when that life also includes distress. A laugh does not prove that someone is fine, and being able to make others laugh does not mean they never need support. We do not have to flatten a complicated person into either constant gloom or constant confidence.

Connection and a sense of purpose

Churchill's correspondence with Clementine helps bring the private person into focus. The Churchill Archive highlights a March 1916 letter in which she discusses his future, supports his interests, and expresses how much she wants time with him. His story included an ongoing relationship, not just solitary resolve.7

There is something useful in that for the rest of us: resilience need not mean becoming self-sufficient. It can include making room for another person to understand what is happening. For some readers, faith or community may also provide meaning; for others, that meaning may come from relationships, creativity, or everyday commitments.

The legacy: hope without romanticizing suffering

Churchill's story is more useful when we let it remain human. His creative interests and capacity to reengage with life are worth noticing. But we cannot conclude that depression made him a great leader, that distress was necessary for his achievements, or that determination alone resolved it.

The encouraging lesson is that a difficult period need not contain the whole story of a life. There can also be curiosity, companionship, pleasure, and meaningful activity. You do not have to turn suffering into an extraordinary accomplishment for your recovery to be worthwhile.

What support can look like today

The options available now extend far beyond learning from a historical figure's coping habits. Depression can be treated with psychotherapy, medication, or both. When those approaches do not provide enough relief, other options—including brain-stimulation treatments—may be considered with a qualified professional.8

If low mood, loss of interest, changes in sleep, or other symptoms persist or interfere with daily life, an assessment can help clarify what is happening and what might help. Enjoyable activities and supportive relationships can sit alongside professional care; they do not need to compete with it.8

You can take inspiration from Churchill's creativity without being asked to copy his life. Finding your own sources of support and relief is a hopeful, practical place to begin.

By Birk Gundersen, RN, BSN 7/9/2023

Words worth knowing

Black box warning

The FDA’s most prominent medication warning, used when a medicine carries a serious or potentially life-threatening risk.

References

  1. Churchill to Clementine, July 11, 1911 — letter excerpt reproduced by The Churchill Project from Mary Soames's edited correspondence
  2. Daniels AM, Vale JA (2018) — Did Sir Winston Churchill suffer from the 'black dog'? Archival study, Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine
  3. Winston S. Churchill — Painting as a Pastime (primary-source essay)
  4. National Trust — Churchill's studio at Chartwell
  5. Churchill Archive — The Power of Words: writing, wit, and oratory
  6. NobelPrize.org — The Nobel Prize in Literature 1953
  7. Churchill Archive — interpreting personal correspondence, including Clementine's March 25, 1916 letter
  8. National Institute of Mental Health — Depression: symptoms, assessment, and treatment

Uncovering Winston Churchill's Shocking Struggle with Mental Health

Watch on YouTube

Educational content—not medical advice.Find support resources →